Archive | physics RSS feed for this section
Image

The Universe Inside Us

3 Apr
Image

All Life is Interconnected

2 Apr
Image

Quantum Coherence

10 Mar
Image

Galaxy of Neurons

16 Feb
Image

Life- Continual Transformation

15 Feb

Veiled Reality: Affirmations of the Apophatic from Physics

2 Feb

Chapter 9 Veiled Reality: Affirmations of the Apophatic from Physics – The God
is No-Thing An Apophatic Assertion: An Introduction for Humankind’s
Transpersonal Actualization– revised -. Copyright Rodger Ricketts Psy.D.,2023.
All rights reserved. Protected by international copyright conventions. No part of
this chapter may be reproduced in any manner whatsoever, or stored in a
retrieval system or transmitted, without express permission of the
Authorpublisher, except in the case of brief quotations with due
acknowledgement.
Chapter 9

Veiled Reality: Affirmations of the Apophatic from Physics
We have seen that science supports the apophatic assertion that a
transcendent reality is beyond the normal range of human perception

and conceptualization. Yet, at the same time, the Transcendent is a
reality in the human life process. We have also seen that awakening or
transcending the ignorance of duality is a common experience of the
mystic. I will now highlight how the theoretical physicist Bernard
d’Espagnat argues that we cannot directly know the transcendental
reality or mind-independent reality:

When, in its spirit, quantum theory and Bell’s theorem are used as
touchstones, the two main traditional philosophical approaches,
realism and idealism, are found wanting. A more suitable
conception seems to be an intermediate one, in which the mere
postulated existence of a holistic and hardly knowable MindIndependent Reality is found to have explaining power. […] This
model considers Reality as not lying in space and time, indeed
being a priori to both, and it involves the view that the great
mathematical laws of physics may only let us catch some glimpses
on the structures of the Mind-Independent Reality.

(On Physics and Philosophy (2006) vol. 41)
D’Espagnat calls this model “veiled reality” to suggest that the
mind-independent reality, like the transcendental of transcendental
idealism, is, for the most part, unconceptualizable. “Veiled reality”
refers to a “world” independent from human perception, brain structure,
and the language of our minds’ participation in knowledge. D’Espagnat,
as well as others, also assert that we are directly involved in this
actuality; we exist in it. We are an integral part of the actual. We are
“swimming” in it. Reality is not a specific area of the universe that
exists separate from our senses. Our limitation is that we can delineate only an exceedingly small aspect of it.

As the Buddha taught, d’Espagnat explains that sense impressions
and sensations are genuine, as are our sense organs. In sight and color,
both the photons, or waves, as well as the retinal cones are actual and
their interactions create our vision. The same is true of our other
sensations. This is the middle way of understanding our place in reality.
We do not have to seek our participation in it; we are a part of it.
However, in our dualistically based ignorance, we normally take our
cognitive representations, or pictures of reality, to be reality itself.
However, under certain meditative conditions, we can understand how
our subject/object dualistic world creates this illusion—the illusion that
is our ignorance.

As the Buddha explained in a descriptive explanation of the
doctrine of kamma and dependent origination, life has a certain
predictability; certain conditions have their origins in certain other

conditions. Life is not total randomness, but it is also not total
determinism. We see a similar approach in d’Espagnat’s account of the
“veiled reality”; we know we are participating in it when we obtain
approximately the same results, regardless of our methods of
investigating a phenomenon or replicating behaviors. Stability is a
reliable criterion of reality. In other words, a reasonable or practical
attitude is one that recognizes that events can be created when a certain
cause or causes originate them.

Space and Time
The Buddha’s teachings suggest that how we experience time and space

has important implications. As Buddhist Scholar Sue Hamilton (2000)
notes,
[…] if the structure of the world of experience is correlated with
the cognitive process, then it is not just that we name objects,
concrete and abstract, and superimpose secondary
characteristics according to the senses. It is also that all the
structural features of the world of experience are cognitively

correlated. Space and time are not external to the structure but
are part of it.

Therefore, everything that is knowable in temporal and spatial
terms is dependent on our subjective cognitive process. In the Buddhist
Sutta, “There is no first beginning, no first beginning is knowable.”
(Samyutta Nikaya 15.1-2) Hamilton continues,
If the entirety of the structure of the world as we know it is
subjectively dependent, including space and time, it follows that
the very concept of there being origins, beginnings, ends, extents,
limits, boundaries, and so on, is subject-dependent. The entirety
of temporality and of spatial extension are concepts which do
not
operate independently of subjective cognitive processes.

Indeed, as discussed in a previous chapter, language has
significant influence on our concepts and experience of reality. In her
study How Languages Construct Time, (2011), Lera Boroditsky
summarized:

How people conceptualize time appears to depend on how the
languages they speak tend to talk about time—the current
linguistic
context, what language is being spoken, and also the
particular metaphors being used to talk about time in the moment.
Further, people who conceptualize space differently also
conceptualize time differently, suggesting that people co-opt
representations of the physical wo
rld/space in order to mentally
represent more abstract or intangible entities. Taken all together,
these findings show that conceptions of even such fundamental
domains as time differs dramatically across cultures and group
s;
the results reveal some of the mechanisms through which
languages and cultures help construct basic notions of time.

The influence of language over thought patterns is deeply pervasive,
affecting even basic concepts such as space and time.
While the transcendental idealism model assumes that reality is
embedded in space and time, in contrast, the Buddha and other
apophatic mystics teach that space and time do not exist outside of us
but are a part of our cognitive constructions, observing and reckoning
the transformation or the constant change of reality. Renowned
theoretical physicist John L. Bell explains it thus: “Gödel explained it
this way… there could be no such thing as an objective lapse of time,
that time or, more generally, change, is an illusion arising from our
special mode of perception.”
Or as the information philosopher Ruth
Kastner wrote, “Time is the measurement of change.” Angelus Silesius
says, “Time is of your own making, Its clock ticks in your head. The
moment you stop thought Time too stops d
ead.”

The physicist d’Espagnat takes a similar position:
I am therefore inclined to think that ‘the Real’—alias human
independent reality
is not embedded in space-time. And indeed,
I go as far as speculating that, quite the contrary, the nature of
space-time is […] not ‘nominal but phenomenal,’ that space-time
is a ‘reality’—for us.

He emphasizes the fact that our experience of space-time is subjective
to our cognitive constructions of phenomena.
Wolfram Schommers takes a similar perspective on space and
time:

We normally assume that our sensations produced by the brain
ar
e identical with reality itself, but this should not be the case as
we have argued that
space-time cannot be outside the brain
because space-time has to be considered as an auxiliary element
for the representation of physically real proces
ses. In other words,
the outside world, the material bodies, cannot be embedde
d in
space-time….Space and time are obviously elements of the brain;
they come into existence due to specific brain functions.

(1998)
This model asserts that even space and time are intimately linked
in our cognitive experience, resulting in a composition of a reality
constructed by our cognitive representations. All form is temporary,
transforming, and impermanent, including (X). Instead, there is the
Present and the constant transformation of manifestations. Or as
physicist David Bohm said, “Ultimately all moments are really one.
Therefore, now is eternity.”

What is Important to You? – Personal Reflections

5 Jan

What things do you think you cannot live without?

I was asked to answer this question and in fact, this is an important and complex one. Upon reflection, there are many important conditions that I cannot live without.

Much of what I cannot live without are my body’s physical necessities for survival, such as oxygen, clean water, nutrients, warmth and coolness, protection from the elements, movement, sleep, etc. Without all these and other, similar factors, my life would be short and miserable. Therefore, I am careful to honor these requirements by being mindful that I include them, in the right quantities and good quality, in my life, thus allowing me to maintain sound physical health.

When my body is in a state of healthy balance, with a good physical foundation and salutary environment, my emotions and thoughts are uplifted and positive and I am much less likely to become depressed or anxious. My life will not be constricted or unhappy. Also, I cannot live well without the wisdom of maintaining a balanced perspective on life and my place in it.

And then there is the spiritual-social aspect. By this, I mean an intuitive knowing that everything is interconnected and interdependent within the mysterious universe. A quote from Albert Einstein expresses this well: ‘The most beautiful and deepest experience a man can have is the sense of the mysterious. It is the underlying principle of religion as well as all serious endeavor in art and science. He who never had this experience seems to me, if not dead, then at least blind. The sense that behind anything that can be experienced there is something that our mind can not grasp and whose beauty and sublimity reaches us only indirectly and as a feeble reflection, this is religiousness. In this sense I am religious. To me, it suffices to wonder about these secrets and to attempt humbly to grasp with my mind a mere image of the lofty structure of all that there is.’

This perspective prevents a feeling of alienation since I know that all the creatures on this earth are a part of the larger universal life force that we share together. All beings on all levels want to thrive; we are all intertwined in the web of life. We are all together.

This brings me to the point of how I came to know and value this experience of oneness. When I was younger, I went on many extended camping trips with friends. In the wilderness, I came to see not only the wondrousness and vastness of the universe but also my companionship, on this planet, with all other living beings including the forests, plants, animals, insects and so forth. Then, finally, after a long search to clarify this discernment for myself, first with awareness training and then the meditative and ethical Buddha’s Path and Satori, I came to clearly understand the oneness of everything with the subsequent empathy and compassion for all life in this world. This insight I cannot live well without.

So, I cannot live without the requirements of life, which means
having shelter, and other necessities that support my physical needs and provide me with the basic comfort I need to thrive. I cannot live happily and be satisfied without knowing my inherent inter-connection with everything alive on this earth. I cannot live happily without the simple expressions of my interests and activities. Finally, I cannot live well without actively expressing my feelings of connectedness and openness, on various levels, with all who share the gift of life.

Overall, besides the requirements for the survival and thriving of my physical life, the foundation of my happiness and satisfaction and my guiding principle is the spiritual aspect of feeling the affinity, interconnectedness, and interdependency of all life on this planet. This is always a feeling I know and honor through my empathic and considerate interactions in life.

Rodger R Ricketts 2021

Image

Mystery of Life

4 Jan
Image

Mysterious Ultimate Reality

4 Jan

Reflections about The Buddha’s Teaching: Seeing Without Illusion

18 Dec

Rodger R Ricketts, Psy.D.

    The Buddha placed primary importance on our thinking and volition. In fact, our difficulties arise when our thinking is unwholesome, in the past and in the present. Our citta or heart/mind is our kingdom or our own mentality. It is our private place where the swirl of thoughts continually passes across our mind. Only you can know what truly goes on there. There is both privacy and the possible control to think the thoughts you want. You can choose which thoughts to accept or refuse. Whichever thoughts you allow will shortly be expressed through your volition in the outer environment. Once you think the thoughts, you cannot take them back. Your choice lies in thinking or not thinking about them in the first place. The more you think unwholesome thoughts, it is like taking a substance that will sicken you both physically and mentally. What your mind dwells on will sooner or later become your ‘world’ and you will attract those energies to you. To entertain and encourage thoughts and feelings of anger, jealousy, resentment, greed, etc., is certain to not only damage your health in some way but also cause a lot of trouble and suffering in your life. So, the Buddha taught you to be Mindful or aware from every moment onwards, to watch even your habitual thinking with utmost care and nurture and promote only wholesome and skillful thinking. May All Beings Be Well and Happy.

The Buddha emphatically declared that the first beginning of existence is something inconceivable. “When this exists, that comes to be; with the arising of this, that arises. When
this does not exist, that does not come to be; with the cessation of this, that ceases, namely: dependent on ignorance, arise volitional formations … and so on … Thus is the ending of this whole mass of suffering.” There is a flux of
psychological and physiological changes, a conflux of mind and body (nāma-rūpa). Anamatagga Saṃyutta, S II 179
‘And even now in physics, they say that ‘Now’ is not something that moves forward but it is the empirically-always-present field of change which is the domain in which events are created. Therefore, the future is always indeterminate and creating new possibilities opening for genuine free will.’ Ruth E. Kastner

The young man said to the Buddha, ‘I will take up the Eightfold Path when I am older, but first I want to enjoy myself and have fun.’ Many people have this idea that by following the Eightfold Path they will be giving up things like intense sense pleasures and self-importance as well as riches and beautiful objects that they will regret not having experienced later. Instead this misses the big picture which is that what one truly comes to sacrifice by personal development through the Buddha’s teachings is selfishness, fear, alienation, insecurity, physical malady, unwholesome pleasures, pride, vanity, doubt, jealousy, self-pity, cravings, anger, hatred, etc. and, instead, what one gains through the Bhavana training includes immeasurably more happiness, peace, joy, compassion, bliss, serenity and vastly improved relationships with all sentient beings as well as oneself. So only giving up things that are not truly worth having and instead of gaining that which is, is the final ample compensation for proceeding diligently on the Eightfold Path until achieving Enlightenment.

The Buddha gave to all a practical method (Eightfold Path) for the development of the mind and heart for the shaping of our lives to eventually achieve Awakening or Enlightenment. He did not teach theology or doctrinal orthodoxy. The Buddha understood that all religious doctrines and theology are human inventions built up by the particular authors out of their own mentalities and foisted on people’s minds from the outside. Instead, The Buddha was the teacher who gave the lessons and, if we so want, we are the ones who practice sincerely what he taught and thereby develop our own insights and knowledge of especially the primary Three Universal Truths of Impermanence, No-Self and the existence of Suffering. In Buddhism, this is entirely a matter that each individual has to settle for him/herself. But if one makes the effort sincerely- the benefits appear immediately.

A wonderful and powerful practice is with especially people we have difficulty with but also all people- when you see or interact with that difficult person imagine seeing their living Buddha Nature and then you will see the layers and type of ignorance with which you are interacting. This practice is good for not only maintaining our own composure but also helps in our judgment of the difficulty of the situation. With metta.

The Realms or Worlds from ‘hell’ to ‘heaven’ are commonly described as extra-human realms but they are also instructive to us when viewed as all our ranges of mental experience created by our conscious as well as non-conscious mental or cognitive processes.

 Whatever we give our attention to is what governs our life – mentally and physically. We have freedom in our ability to choose what we direct and maintain our attention on. What we consistently pay attention to becomes our ‘world’ and habitually dominates it. If we constantly direct our attention on the ever-changing, impermanent outer world we suffer anxiety and uncertainty; if we direct our attention on nothing then nothing, in particular, is expressed in our life with uncertainty and boredom. If we direct our attention to the four divine internal states and eventually arrive at Emptiness we experience happiness/bliss, good health, compassion, wisdom and certainty in the Truth of the Four Noble Truths.

Metta (loving-kindness) is defined as follows: Loving-kindness has the mode of friendliness for its characteristic. Its natural function is to promote friendliness. It is manifested as the disappearance of ill-will. Its footing is seeing with kindness. When it succeeds it eliminates ill-will. When it fails it degenerates into selfish affectionate desire. Eventually, one can begin to practice loving-kindness towards a dearly beloved companion, and then towards a neutral person as very dear, or towards an enemy as neutral. It is when dealing with an enemy that anger can arise, and all means must be tried to get rid of it. As soon as this has succeeded, one will be able to regard an enemy without resentment and with loving-kindness in the same way as one does the admired person, the dearly loved friend and the neutral person. Then with repeated practice, jhana absorption should be attained in all cases. Loving-kindness can now be effectively maintained in being towards all beings.

Ñanamoli Thera

However, those who believe in a soul only too often override the limits set by experience and concern themselves with “something completely unknowable,” as Bertrand Russell says. Moving along these wrong tracks of thought, they readily admit that all cognizable and experiential constituents of the “personality” are subject to constant change, to an unceasing rise and fall; and for that reason, they, of course, cannot be considered as an abiding ego. But it is, so they believe, just from behind or beyond the cognizable and experiential components of the personality that the true eternal self or soul appears which, naturally, must be beyond cognition and experience. What is wrong in such a position and in these conclusions, has chiefly to be attributed to the fact that an empty concept has been raised to the dignity of man’s true essence or core—a concept obtained by mere abstract ratiocination, having nothing in common with observation and experience. The futility of such a play with words has been shown by Kant. For him, a way of thinking that transgresses the limits drawn by experience is playing with ideas, and the alleged vision of something imperceptible is “a poetic fiction transcending everything imaginable, a mere whim.” The Buddha and his monks, however, are no dreamers chasing after metaphysical phantoms. They are sober realists who will not admit such groundless speculations even to the range of their considerations or refutations. Dr. Anton Kropatsch, Vienna

I’ve looked at life from both sides now

From up and down and still somehow

It’s life’s illusions I recall

I really don’t know life at all -Joni Mitchell

This is the true question that the Buddha’s teachings really address – ‘Do I Really Know Life At All?’ And in investigating the question, the answer becomes quite clear- for the uninvestigated mind, No…I don’t. All existence is much too complex, interrelated, and deep for us prideful humans to truly comprehend and indeed mystery is the result. But this is not a defeat but an affirmation of our embeddedness and interrelatedness with All of other existence. Not the folly, alienation, and separateness of the conceit of humans being the supreme being of the universe or even earth but the authentic identification of the true ecological, co-arising nature of all things. You will hear people say, ‘I am trying to find myself.’ But if you want to find yourself, then transcend yourself. When we transcend our-self, we truly find each other and our interconnection with all. We are not alone! Just look around you, there are creatures of life everywhere. If we feel alone, that is our blindness to life all around us, our suffering of alienation created by the illusion of separateness and ‘I’.

The Buddha understood how humans create “conceptual proliferation”- thinking, a representational and abstracting process that they believe and attach to. This is another way to speak about that:
‘When the animals evolved the talent to produce a virtual presence, they acquired a soul.
Then there was a God to be adored.
And an Adam was created.
As the production of virtual presences increases, man’s tie to the Real decreases. Soon, he praises innovation and inhuman courage. He invents thrills and excitement. He relies on myths and mysteries. He downgrades Nature with a reckless chisel. Life becomes the Grand Illusion. With a facility in the manipulation of virtual presences, the primal Superman was born. With perfection in the art, a second Devil took charge. It was then that man came to defy the God. The interminable conflict thrusting the virtual presences against the real intensifies.’ R. G. H. Siu

Upon Awakening the Buddha realized emptiness and the illusion of duality and a substantial Self- the consequences of the ignorance of dualistic thinking is expressed well in the following quote by Professor l. k. Tong-‘And so you opted for the substantialist’s art of self-making, Cutting off all umbilical cords to the Mother of Field-Being. You first dignify yourself in the kingly robes of an independent entity, enthroning yourself in the lonely kingdom of ego-substance. Then with the projective magic of your subjective substantiality, you objectify everything on your way to Godlike rigidity. And with the pointing of the substantializing wand, a bond was broken; a shade of mutuality has withered and waned. Now everything becomes merely external and separate from everything else. External is your objective world, you objectified a God, and your objectified self. Anything you cannot safely possess and control you relegate to the dark side of the Other, the Hell, the objective pole, and condemned it as ugly, or evil. Oh, in carrying your Godlike rigidity to all eternity (as if you were in fact rigidly eternal), you, a virtuoso in dualization, have created the most unhappy situation.’

In the Kalama Sutta, the Buddha said, ‘Now, Kalamas, don’t go by reports, by legends, by traditions, by scripture, by logical conjecture, by inference, by analogies, by agreement through pondering views, by probability, or by the thought, ‘This contemplative is our teacher.’ When you know for yourselves that, ‘These qualities are skillful; these qualities are blameless; these qualities are praised by the wise; these qualities, when adopted & carried out, lead to welfare & to happiness’ — then you should enter & remain in them.’ 
Many honest seekers today of the Truth, like the Kalamas, become confused and worried by the many conflicting and inconsistent sects and theologies that are pronounced daily by so many people calling themselves the ‘light to follow’. The Buddha provided a simple and direct test to guide us to know the truth of his teaching: trust yourself, your own experience, and through your experience of the correct teachings which you have found to be reliable and insightful – follow and use. Those people who are “the wise” will teach with the plan that you will see the benefit for yourself through your experience and transformation and not through blind faith and, therefore, you don’t become a slave to their wisdom, instead, you use your reason, your common sense, and your own experience as the ultimate guide and confirmation. So, you develop insights for yourself ultimately. While you can benefit from reading books and listening to teachers, etc., your true reliance is upon your real understanding created through the real work that must ultimately be done in transforming and purifying our individual mind. In the end, you know for yourself the confirmation of the Buddha’s teachings – there is suffering and the ending of suffering- and this is the only authority needed or desirable.

‘To avoid all evil, to cultivate good, and to purify one’s mind—this is the teaching of the Buddhas.’ (Dhammapada 183.) Throughout human history, innumerable plans and schemes and doctrines have been invented to make people happy, serene, and compassionate by making changes in human’s external conditions while leaving the quality of the mentality untouched and the result has over and over again been the same- failure. The Buddha taught that this failure is so because the very nature of our external existence is only changed by the purification of our conscious awareness. The difficulty for human history and never finding the key to happiness and compassion is that purification of one’s mind takes effort, diligence, and devoted practice to be successful. We must have constant unceasing vigilance and mindfulness to break the old unwholesome mental habits which are so troublesome. The Buddha understood this but also understood the benefits that arise when we do the Eightfold Path with the result of Nibbana. ‘This is peace, this is exquisite — the resolution of all fabrications, the relinquishment of all acquisitions, the ending of craving; dispassion; cessation; Nibbana.’— AN 3.32

To purify our mind as the Buddha taught, we need to release any anger or resentment toward others or our self. When we experience hurt, disappointment, deception, etc, from other people, these feelings sink into our memory and cause inflamed and festering emotional/psychological wounds of anger, resentment and possibly revenge. To purify our mind, we need to forgive. Forgiveness is a conscious, willing decision to release any feelings of resentment or vengeance toward a person or group who has harmed you, regardless of whether they deserve your forgiveness. Forgiveness is difficult and it does not mean condoning or excusing offenses, nor does it obligate you to reconcile with the person who harmed you or releases them from accountability. Instead, forgiveness brings the forgiver peace of mind and frees him or her from corrosive anger and resentment. Forgiveness involves letting go of deeply held negative feelings but also maintaining a feeling of at least neutral goodwill toward everyone who may have injured you in any way. In that way, you recognize the pain you suffered without letting that pain define you, enabling you to heal. By forgiveness, you set yourself free from the attachment to the link that you maintain even mentally to the past and the negativity. Setting yourself free from the attachment, releases you. This includes forgiveness of oneself for actions you did that you now understand were unwholesome and unskillful. Through purification and letting go of the guilt or resentment, happiness and peace will follow as well as increased wisdom and equanimity.